One of the decisions you make when buying a fiber laser cutting machine is the frame type: will the cutting area be open, or fully enclosed in a cabin? Both types cut with the same fiber laser technology; the differences lie in safety, fume control, sheet loading, floor space and investment cost. This article compares the two and explains which suits which kind of work.
In short: how the two types differ
On an enclosed machine, a cabin surrounds the cutting area and protects the operator from laser radiation, sparks and fumes. On an open-type machine, the bed is accessible from every side: sheets are easy to load, the machine takes up less space and the investment is lower.
| Open type | Enclosed | |
|---|---|---|
| Operator safety | Provided by measures such as guarding, warning signs and laser safety glasses | Largely provided by the cabin and filtered viewing windows |
| Fumes and dust | Extracted under the bed; extraction and ventilation keep them from spreading | Stay inside the cabin and are collected by the extraction system |
| Sheet loading | Loaded onto the bed from any side by crane or forklift | Loaded through a door or via an exchange table |
| Floor space | Less | More, because of the cabin and the exchange table |
| Investment cost | Lower | Higher |
| Best suited to | Getting started, medium volumes, very large beds | High-volume, multi-shift series production |
Safety: the fiber laser beam is invisible
A fiber laser emits invisible light at a wavelength of about 1 micrometre. Both the direct beam and light reflected from the sheet can cause permanent eye damage, and sparks and spatter during cutting are a separate hazard. So before choosing a frame type, think about who will work at and around the machine.
- On an enclosed machine, the cabin and the laser-filtered viewing windows largely remove this risk. The cabin doors are usually monitored by safety switches, so the laser stops when a door opens.
- On an open-type machine, protection comes from guarding around the machine, warning signs, a work area restricted to trained staff, and safety glasses rated for the laser's wavelength.
- As laser power rises, reflected light and sparks get stronger, so these measures matter even more on high-power machines.
- If people who have nothing to do with the machine also work in the shop, an enclosed machine is the easier way to keep everyone safe.
Fumes, dust and a clean workshop
Laser cutting produces metal vapour and fine dust. On an enclosed machine, these fumes stay inside the cabin and are collected by the extraction system, so less dust settles in the workshop. Open-type machines also extract under the bed, but because the cutting area is open, extraction capacity and workshop ventilation play a bigger role.
- Cutting galvanized sheet produces zinc oxide fumes, which are harmful to breathe; whichever type you choose, do not skimp on extraction and filtration.
- Plan the location of the extraction duct and the filter unit together with the position of the machine.
Sheet loading, floor space and bed size
Because the bed of an open-type machine is accessible from every side, sheets go straight onto it by crane or forklift, and cut parts are easy to remove. Enclosed machines are mostly loaded via an exchange table: while one table is being cut, the other is loaded with a new sheet. This reduces idle time but needs extra floor space.
- When planning floor space, allow for the machine itself plus sheet stock, the loading route, stacking of cut parts and clearance for maintenance.
- On very large beds, an open frame makes sheet loading and maintenance easier. In 2024 we built two open-type fiber laser cutting machines with a 12,000 × 3,000 mm bed, one with 12 kW and the other with 20 kW.
- Among our enclosed models, the DNL 2060 D has a 2 × 6 m bed and a 12 kW fiber laser.
Cost: look beyond the purchase price
An open-type machine usually costs less to buy; the cabin, doors, exchange table and safety equipment add to the price of an enclosed one. Even so, compare the total cost.
- An open-type machine may need extra investment in safety and extraction, such as guarding, safety glasses and stronger ventilation.
- On an enclosed machine, the exchange table increases the share of time the machine spends cutting in high-volume work; in multi-shift operation that time difference feeds straight into cost.
- Electricity, assist gas and consumables depend on laser power and the work being cut on both types, not on the frame type.
Which one suits you?
- Enclosed: if you run more than one shift, cut continuously with a high-power laser, have other staff working in the shop, or fume and dust control is a priority.
- Open type: if you are new to sheet cutting, handle medium volumes or job-shop work, load very large and heavy sheets by crane, or budget and space are the priority.
Doktek Technology manufactures open-type and enclosed CNC fiber laser cutting machines in Denizli, Türkiye. Tell us the material you cut, your thickest sheet, your sheet size and your monthly output, and we will work out the right type and configuration with you.
